Clinical characteristics of pediatric nasal bone fractures by age group

Article information

Arch Craniofac Surg. 2023;24(6):273-277
Publication date (electronic) : 2023 December 20
doi : https://doi.org/10.7181/acfs.2023.00514
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Daegu Catholic University School of Medicine, Daegu, Korea
Correspondence: Dong Gil Han Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Daegu Catholic University School of Medicine, 33 Duryugongwon-ro 17-gil, Nam-gu, Daegu 42472, Korea E-mail: dghan1001@cu.ac.kr
Received 2023 October 4; Revised 2023 November 7; Accepted 2023 December 20.

Abstract

Background

The clinical characteristics of pediatric nasal fractures can vary depending on the child’s age, social activities, and environment. Therefore, this study aimed to analyze these characteristics in different age groups.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed of a series of patients aged under 12 years who received treatment between 2013 and 2021. The initial study design involved dividing the patients into four age groups, corresponding to different developmental ages, but there were no cases in infants aged 0 to 1 year. Therefore, the patients were divided into three groups: group I, between 2 and 5; group II, between 6 and 9; and group III, between 10 and 12 years of age. The following parameters were evaluated: sex, age, etiology, fracture type and severity, and the incidence of septal injuries.

Results

In total, 98 patients were included in this study. In group III, the ratio of boys to girls was 3.88:1, exceeding the overall ratio of 1.97:1. The most common cause varied with age: slipping down in group I, bumping accidents in group II, and sports accidents in group III. Concomitant septal injuries were present in 4.17% of patients in group I, 5.71% of patients in group II, and 28.21% of patients in group III.

Conclusion

Increasing age was accompanied by a greater tendency for male predominance and a higher prevalence of sports-related causes and septal injuries. Violence was infrequent but started to become a contributing factor during school age. These varying environmental factors across age groups can offer valuable insights into the epidemiology and clinical characteristics of pediatric nasal bone fractures.

Keywords: Age; Nasal bone; Pediatrics

INTRODUCTION

Significant differences exist in children’s anatomic characteristics, parental attention and care, social relationships, and social activities according to age, and the age of 12 years has been identified as a noteworthy transition point [1,2]. However, few studies have taken age-specific differences into account, especially in research on nasal bone fractures in pediatric populations. Therefore, the aim of this study was to analyze differences in the characteristics of pediatric nasal fractures in various age groups among children 12 years of age and younger.

METHODS

A retrospective review was conducted of the medical records of pediatric patients aged 12 years or younger who had isolated nasal bone fractures including septal fractures and underwent closed reduction. This study excluded patients with other facial fractures, previous nasal bone fractures, or congenital facial deformities.

Information was extracted on patients’ demographics, including sex, age, etiology, fracture pattern, and the presence of a septal injury. Fractures were evaluated using a dual 128-channel CT scanner (Somatom Definition Flash; Siemens), and the types of nasal bone fractures were classified using the system developed by Stranc and Robertson [3].

For the epidemiological analysis, we initially intended to study four distinct age groups: infants, the first growth period, kindergarten through lower primary school grades, and upper primary school grades. However, due to the absence of patients aged 0–1 year (n= 0), we categorized patients into three groups by developmental age: group I (first growth period), between ages 2 and 5; group II (kindergarten and lower grades of primary school), between ages 6 and 9; group III (upper grades of primary school), between ages 10 and 12 years. Environmental factors were evaluated by age group. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 19.0 (IBM Corp.).

RESULTS

This study included 98 patients (65 boys and 33 girls). Group I (first growth period of the nasal bone) contained 24 patients (12 boys and 12 girls), group II included 35 (22 boys and 13 girls), and group III contained 39 (31 boys and 8 girls) (Table 1). The most common causes of injury were slipping down accidents (13 cases, 54.17%) in group I, bumping accidents (20 cases, 57.14%) in group II, and sports-related accidents (14 cases, 35.90%) in group III (Table 2).

Sex ratio according to age group

Etiology of nasal bone fractures in each age group

The number of patients with a plane I fracture pattern was 23 of 24 in group I (95.83%), 33 of 35 in group II (94.29%), and 32 of 39 in group III (82.05%). The overall incidence of plane I fracture patterns was 89.80%. The number of patients with concomitant septal injuries was one in group I (4.17%), two in group II (5.71%), and 11 in group III (28.21%) (Table 3).

Incidence of plane I fracture patterns and septal injuries by age group

DISCUSSION

Numerous studies have investigated the epidemiology of nasal bone fractures in pediatric populations. However, these studies have either categorized pediatric patients based on age groups relevant to the epidemiology of violence, such as preschool (0–5 years) and school age (6–11 years) [4,5], or they have concentrated on the causes and mechanisms of injury [6]. Another study examined the sex distribution and causes of injury in pediatric patients, dividing the subjects into four age groups (0–3, 4–6, 7–9, and 10–12 years). However, that study included all facial bone fractures, not exclusively nasal bone fractures. As a result, detailed age-specific information on nasal fractures in pediatric patients was not provided [7].

The initial peak growth of the nasal bone occurs between the ages of 2 and 5, followed by a period of gradual growth. During puberty, there is a second significant growth spurt in the bone, along with additional growth of the septum [8,9]. Furthermore, no study seems to have specifically investigated the epidemiology of nasal bone fractures during the critical growth period of the nose (2–5 years) in pediatric patients. With this in mind, we conducted a study on the epidemiology of nasal bone fractures, subdividing the pediatric population into the following age groups: early childhood (2–5 years), lower school age (6–9 years), and upper school age (10–12 years).

In addition, children of varying ages exhibit notable differences in anatomical characteristics, parental involvement in care, social relationship development, and areas of social activity. Hence, to account for age-related differences, we investigated the clinical characteristics of pediatric nasal bone fractures in infants, early childhood in the first growth period, children in kindergarten and the lower grades of primary school, and children in the upper grades of primary school. This study showed that the characteristics of nasal bone fractures vary significantly across pediatric age groups, and several noteworthy findings are discussed below.

The first point to note is that there were no patients who fell into the category of infants (aged 0 to 1 year). This may be attributed to the limited mobility of infants in this age group and the extensive care they typically receive from their parents.

Second, pediatric nasal fractures occurred more frequently in boys than in girls, with 65 cases (66.33%) in boys and 33 cases (33.67%) in girls. However, when analyzed by age group, the number of cases in boys was 12 (50%) out of 24 in group I, 22 (62.86%) out of 35 in group II, and 31 (79.49%) of 39 in group III. In this study, the incidence of nasal fractures was equal between boys and girls during the first growth period. However, by the time children reach the upper grades of primary school, the male-to-female ratio of nasal fractures increased to approximately 4:1, roughly equaling the ratio observed in adults [4,10]. The higher prevalence of nasal fractures among boys in the upper primary grades is thought to result from differences in social and sports activities between boys and girls [11]. This phenomenon becomes markedly more evident in adolescence, during which boys have been reported to account for approximately 90% of nasal fracture patients [12].

Third, regarding the etiology of nasal fractures in the pediatric population, a study conducted in Korea found that the predominant causes were falls or slip-down injuries [4,7]. Consistent with prior research, the primary causes of fractures among the overall pediatric population in this study were collisions with people or objects and slip-and-fall incidents, accounting for 33 (33.67%) and 28 (28.57%) cases, respectively. Other causes included sports-related accidents (19 cases), traffic accidents (10 cases), accidents related to social activities (3 cases), assaults (3 cases), and falls (2 cases).

The most common cause of injury was slipping accidents (13 cases, 54.17%) in group I, bumping accidents (20 cases, 57.14%) in group II, and sports-related accidents (14 cases, 35.90%) in group III. This suggests that, despite increased activity levels in early childhood (group I) during the growth period, the lower extremities may be less developed, leading to a higher propensity for slipping. It can be inferred that the period encompassing kindergarten and the early years of primary school is marked by a significant increase in activity, while there may be less parental supervision than during the initial growth period.

In the pediatric population, accidents related to sports or social activities were observed exclusively within school-age groups, except for one case in group I. Assault injuries were also confined to school-age groups, with one case occurring in the lower grades and two cases in the upper grades of primary school. These findings suggest that social activities, including sports, are more common among school-age children than among those under the age of 6, and that incidents of assault begin to emerge within this age group.

Fourth, it has been reported that the incidence of frontal impact (FI) fractures is significantly higher in preschool and elementary school-aged children than in adolescents and adults, in contrast to lateral impact (LI) fractures [4]. In this study, group I experienced nine cases of FI fractures, 14 cases of LI fractures, and one case of frontal impact plane II (FII) fractures. Group II had 14 FI fractures, 19 LI fractures, and two FII fractures. Group III contained 13 FI fractures, 19 LI fractures, two FII fractures, and five cases of lateral force plane II (LII) fractures. These results show that type I fractures were present in 89.8% of cases, including 41 fractures from FI and 57 from LI. These findings imply that pediatric nasal fractures are typically minor and occur with similar frequency regardless of the child’s age. Additionally, there was no significant difference in the injury vectors between frontal and lateral forces.

Fifth, the incidence of concurrent septal fractures in cases of nasal bone fractures across all age groups has been reported to be 46.9% and 47.4% [13,14]. Septal injuries in pediatric patients with nasal fractures are of particular concern because they may impair facial growth by disrupting a growth center [15]. However, it remains uncertain whether a nasal bone fracture alone could contribute to septal deviation in adults, even in the absence of a septal fracture [16].

In this study, the overall number of septal injuries in patients with pediatric nasal fractures was 14 (14.29%). There was one patient with a septal injury out of 24 patients (4.17%) in group I, as well as two of 35 patients (5.71%) in group II and 11 of 39 patients (28.21%) in group III. These results suggest that the risk of septal injury is relatively low during the first growth period. However, there is a statistically significant increase in risk as children advance to the higher grades of primary school (p< 0.05). Notably, the incidence of septal injuries in uppergrade students was nearly five times greater than that in children attending kindergarten and the lower grades of primary school (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1.

Incidence of septal injuries by age group. There was one patient with septal injury out of 24 patients (4.17%) in group I, as well as two of 35 patients (5.71%) in group II, and 11 of 39 patients (28.21%) in group III. The probability of septal injury increased with age, and the prevalence of septal injuries in the upper grades was about five times higher than that in the lower grades of primary school.

Although this study identified clear differences in nasal bone fractures among pediatric patients across various age groups, limitation is that the findings are based solely on patients who underwent surgical treatment. To achieve a more comprehensive understanding of this condition, further research that includes patients who received conservative treatment is necessary. Additionally, pediatric nasal fractures pose challenges due to injuries to the cartilage framework, which often lead to secondary nasal deformities and a higher risk of long-term functional or external nasal issues, even with accurate diagnosis and optimal treatment [17,18]. Therefore, it is essential to assess objective outcomes during long-term follow-up, categorized by age group.

The present study compared clinical characteristics of nasal bone fractures during early childhood, later childhood, and the growth period of the nose, taking into account differences in developmental environments and the impact of growth spurts. This comparison may offer valuable insights into the nature of pediatric nasal bone fractures.

Notes

Conflict of interest

No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.

Funding

None.

Ethical approval

The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Daegu Catholic University Medical Center (IRB No. CR-23-057-L) and performed in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. The informed consent was waived.

Author contributions

Conceptualization; Data curation; Formal analysis: Dong Gil Han. Methodology; Project administration: Jun Woo Kim, Dong Gil Han. Visualization: Jun Woo Kim. Writing - original draft: Jun Woo Kim, Dong Gil Han. Writing - review & editing: Jun Woo Kim, Dong Gil Han. Investigation: Jun Woo Kim, Dong Gil Han. Resources; Software: Jun Woo Kim. Supervision; Validation: Dong Gil Han.

Abbreviations

FI

frontal impact

FII

frontal impact plane II

LI

lateral impact

LII

lateral force plane II

References

1. Wright RJ, Murakami CS, Ambro BT. Pediatric nasal injuries and management. Facial Plast Surg 2011;27:483–90.
2. Meier JD, Tollefson TT. Pediatric facial trauma. Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2008;16:555–61.
3. Stranc MF, Robertson GA. A classification of injuries of the nasal skeleton. Ann Plast Surg 1979;2:468–74.
4. Yu H, Jeon M, Kim Y, Choi Y. Epidemiology of violence in pediatric and adolescent nasal fracture compared with adult nasal fracture: an 8-year study. Arch Craniofac Surg 2019;20:228–32.
5. Liu C, Legocki AT, Mader NS, Scott AR. Nasal fractures in children and adolescents: mechanisms of injury and efficacy of closed reduction. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 2015;79:2238–42.
6. Segura-Palleres I, Sobrero F, Roccia F, de Oliveira Gorla LF, Pereira-Filho VA, Gallafassi D, et al. Characteristics and agerelated injury patterns of maxillofacial fractures in children and adolescents: a multicentric and prospective study. Dent Traumatol 2022;38:213–22.
7. Kim SH, Lee SH, Cho PD. Analysis of 809 facial bone fractures in a pediatric and adolescent population. Arch Plast Surg 2012;39:606–11.
8. Verwoerd CD, Verwoerd-Verhoef HL. Rhinosurgery in children: basic concepts. Facial Plast Surg 2007;23:219–30.
9. Alcaraz N, Lawson W. Trauma of the nose and nasoethmoid complex in children and adolescents. Facial Plast Surg Clin N Am 1999;7:175–83.
10. Choi MH, Cheon JS, Son KM, Choi WY. Long-term postoperative satisfaction and complications in nasal bone fracture patients according to fracture type, site, and severity. Arch Craniofac Surg 2020;21:7–14.
11. Kang WK, Han DG, Kim SE, Lee YJ, Shim JS. Comparison of postoperative outcomes between early and delayed surgery for pediatric nasal fractures. Arch Craniofac Surg 2021;22:93–8.
12. Kim SH, Han DG, Shim JS, Lee YJ, Kim SE. Clinical characteristics of adolescent nasal bone fractures. Arch Craniofac Surg 2022;23:29–33.
13. Yoon YJ, Lee HI, Lee YS, Lee WH, Cho JE, Park HW, et al. Radiologic analysis of nasal septal fracture in nasal bone fracture patients through computerized tomography. Korean J Otorhinolaryngol-Head Neck Surg 2007;50:903–6.
14. Hong SB, Choi BW, Suh IS, Ha JW. Clinical & radiological evaluation of the nasal bone fractures. J Korean Soc Plast Reconstr Surg 1996;23:1572–82.
15. Verwoerd CD, Verwoerd-Verhoef HL. Rhinosurgery in children: developmental and surgical aspects of the growing nose. GMS Curr Top Otorhinolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2010;9:Doc05.
16. Choi JH, Oh HM, Hwang JH, Kim KS, Lee SY. Do closed reduction and fracture patterns of the nasal bone affect nasal septum deviation? Arch Craniofac Surg 2022;23:119–24.
17. Wheeler J, Phillips J. Pediatric facial fractures and potential long-term growth disturbances. Craniomaxillofac Trauma Reconstr 2011;4:43–52.
18. Aldelaimi TN. New maneuver for fixation of pediatric nasal bone fracture. J Craniofac Surg 2011;22:1476–8.

Article information Continued

Fig. 1.

Incidence of septal injuries by age group. There was one patient with septal injury out of 24 patients (4.17%) in group I, as well as two of 35 patients (5.71%) in group II, and 11 of 39 patients (28.21%) in group III. The probability of septal injury increased with age, and the prevalence of septal injuries in the upper grades was about five times higher than that in the lower grades of primary school.

Table 1.

Sex ratio according to age group

Sex Group I (2–5 yr) Group II (6–9 yr) Group III (10–12 yr) p-value
Boy 12 22 31
Girl 12 13 8
Ratio (boy:girl) 1:1 1.69:1 3.88:1 0.048a)
a)

The p-values were calculated using the chi-square test. The sex ratio among the three groups showed a statistically significant difference (p<0.05).

Table 2.

Etiology of nasal bone fractures in each age group

Etiology Group I (2–5 yr) Group II (6–9 yr) Group III (10–12 yr) p-valuea)
Falling down 2 0 0 0.043
Traffic accidents 4 1 5 0.178
Slipping down 13 8 7 0.005
Bumping accidents 3 20 10 0.001
Sports 1 4 14 0.003
Social activity-related accidents 1 1 1 0.934
Assault 0 1 2 0.516
a)

The p-values were calculated using the chi-square test. The most common cause of injury was slipping down accident (13 cases: 54.16%) in group I, a bumping accident (20 cases: 57.15%) in group II, and a sports-related accident (14 cases: 35.90%) in group III. The three aforementioned factors each exhibit a statistically significant incidence in group I, group II, and group III, with p<0.05. Falling down also exhibits a statistically significant incidence in group I (p<0.05), which is considered reasonable given that group I encompasses an age range of 2 to 5 years.

Table 3.

Incidence of plane I fracture patterns and septal injuries by age group

Group Plane I fractures Septal injuries
Group I (2–5 yr) 23/24 (95.83) 1/24 (4.17)
Group II (6–9 yr) 33/35 (94.29) 2/35 (5.71)
Group III (10–12 yr) 32/39 (82.05) 11/39 (28.21)
p-value > 0.060a) > 0.006b)

Values are represented as numbers (%).

a)

The p-values were calculated using the chi-square test. The comparison among the three groups for plane I fractures versus plane II fractures or higher did not yield statistical significance (p>0.05);

b)

These results suggest that the risk of septal injury was relatively low during the first growth period of the nose and increased to a statistically significant extent as children progressed to the upper grades of primary school (p<0.05).